May 21, 2019
VIA EDGAR SUBMISSION
Rebekah Lindsey
Division of Corporation Finance
Office of Consumer Products
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Re: Ribbon Communications Inc.
Form 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2018
Filed March 4, 2019
Form 8-K furnished February 20, 2019
File No. 001-38267
Dear Ms. Lindsey:
Ribbon Communications Inc. (the Company) is pleased to respond to the comments of the staff (the Staff) of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the Commission) contained in your letter dated April 30, 2019. For ease of reference, the comments are repeated in italics below and followed by the Companys responses.
Form 8-K Furnished on February 20, 2019
General
1. We note your adjustment for acquisition-related revenue included in your various non-GAAP measures. Considering your deferred revenue was adjusted to fair value at the time of acquisition pursuant to GAAP, please tell us how you considered whether your various non-GAAP measures that include this adjustment are substituting an individually tailored recognition and measurement method for a GAAP measure. Refer to Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations and Rule 100(b) of Regulation G.
RESPONSE
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staffs comment. The Company believes its inclusion of acquisition-related revenue adjustments in its non-GAAP financial measures for the periods presented was not an individually tailored revenue recognition method in violation of Rule 100(b) of Regulation G or inconsistent with the Staffs guidance in Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations (Question 100.04).
The acquisition-related, or purchase accounting, adjustments noted in the Staffs comment were calculated in accordance with Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 805 Business Combinations, and have been significant to the Companys reported results since its merger with GENBAND Holdings Company, GENBAND, Inc. and GENBAND II, Inc. (collectively, GENBAND), which occurred on October 27, 2017 (the Merger). In connection with the Merger, it was required under ASC 805 to record at fair value GENBANDs assumed deferred revenue, resulting in a reduction of approximately $50 million to the assumed deferred revenue and future recognizable revenue. Similarly, in connection with the Companys subsequent acquisition of Edgewater Networks, Inc. (Edgewater), which occurred on August 3,
2018 (the Edgewater Acquisition and, together with the Merger, the Transactions), the Company was required under ASC 805 to record at fair value the assumed Edgewater deferred revenue, resulting in a reduction of approximately $4 million to the assumed deferred revenue and future recognizable revenue. The Companys GAAP revenue, net loss and loss per share have excluded revenue resulting from these purchase accounting adjustments since the respective acquisition dates. These adjustments aggregated approximately $54 million of future revenue that would have been recognized had these acquisitions not occurred and had each company continued to report its revenue on a standalone basis.
In its non-GAAP financial measures, the Company elected to include the amount of revenue related to the purchase accounting adjustments to deferred revenue that would have been recognized in each period. The Company believes that these adjustments are relatively short-term items that can materially impact revenue in the periods after an acquisition. Therefore, as a supplement to Ribbons GAAP results, the adjustment provides investors the ability to compare Ribbons trends quarter-over-quarter and also facilitates a comparison to the results of competitors. These adjustments are limited to the revenue eliminated by the purchase accounting adjustments to deferred revenue.
Question 100.04 focuses on a scenario where an adjustment accelerates the recognition of revenue. The Companys purchase accounting revenue adjustments did not adjust the timing of revenue recognition, but rather, included revenue that would otherwise not have been recognized because of the purchase accounting reduction to the deferred revenue assumed in the Transactions.
2. Similarly, please clarify for us what the purchase accounting adjustment to cost of revenue consists of and how you considered whether your various non-GAAP measures that include this adjustment are substituting an individually tailored recognition and measurement method for a GAAP measure. Refer to Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations and Rule 100(b) of Regulation G.
RESPONSE
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staffs comment. The purchase accounting adjustments to cost of revenue consist of the amount of expense attributable to the non-GAAP purchase accounting adjustments to revenue for each period presented. Having included the deferred revenue in the non-GAAP financial measures, had the Company not included the associated costs, it would have overstated the applicable non-GAAP gross margins, net income, earnings (loss) per share and adjusted EBITDA. The Company believes that these cost of revenue adjustments provide investors with a useful comparison to the Companys historical financial measures and assist investors in assessing the Companys core operating results.
3. You state that GAAP required the elimination of revenue under the new revenue recognition standard in 2018, which you are adding back to arrive at various non-GAAP measures. Please clarify for us what revenue was eliminated with the adoption of ASC 606 and how your non-GAAP adjustment for such amounts captures the economics of your activities. Also, please confirm for us that similar adjustments will not be made to fiscal 2019 non-GAAP measures.
RESPONSE
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staffs comment. The non-GAAP adjustments to revenue related to the Companys adoption of ASC 606 represent the amounts that would have been recognized in each period if the Company had not been required to write off approximately $12 million of its deferred revenue balance at January 1, 2018. This amount is consistent with our required transition period GAAP disclosures of the impact of the adoption of ASC 606. We believe this adjustment assists investors in comparing our 2018 amounts with prior year amounts that were reported under ASC 605.
The Company removed this adjustment from its non-GAAP measures for the first quarter of 2019 and confirms that similar adjustments will not be made to its non-GAAP measures in the remainder of fiscal 2019 or in future periods.
4. We note your non-GAAP net income reconciliation includes income tax adjustments related to benefits arising from purchase accounting and the Tax Reform. Please explain to us, and revise your future filings to disclose, how you calculated the tax effects of your non-GAAP net income adjustments. In this regard, your tax adjustment
should also include current and deferred income tax expense commensurate with your non-GAAP measure of profitability. Refer to Question 102.11 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
RESPONSE
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staffs comment. The adjustment to the income tax line in the Companys non-GAAP reconciliation table for the year ended December 31, 2018 represents the elimination of a $0.7 million income tax benefit related to the partial release of the Companys valuation allowance in connection with the acquisition of Edgewater. The adjustment to the income tax line for the year ended December 31, 2017 was comprised of $16.4 million from the reduction to our valuation allowance in connection with the Merger and $4.8 million related to the Tax Reform. As part of the purchase accounting related to the Transactions, the Company recorded net deferred tax liabilities, which provided incremental future taxable income and associated releases of the Companys preexisting valuation allowance. Pursuant to ASC 805-740-30-3, such releases are recorded outside the business combination as a benefit to income. The Company believes that such tax benefits are not part of its core business or ongoing operations, as they do not relate to revenue-producing activities. Accordingly, the Company believes that excluding the net benefits arising from the Transactions and the Tax Reform facilitates the comparison of its financial results to its historical results and to other companies in its industry.
In accordance with Question 102.11 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations, the Companys adjustments to net income are presented on a gross basis and are not net of tax. Based on the Company having significant net operating losses (NOLs) and an associated valuation allowance that would be available to substantially offset the tax expense associated with these non-GAAP adjustments, the income tax line in the non-GAAP net income reconciliation table did not reflect any tax impact from the Companys non-GAAP adjustments to net income (apart from the tax impact of the adjustments for purchase accounting and tax reform, as discussed above).
In accordance with the Staffs comment, in future earnings releases the Company will enhance its disclosure in the section on non-GAAP net income (loss) through discussion of the impact of its NOLs and related valuation allowance, and any other relevant factors, on the tax consequences arising from its non-GAAP adjustments.
We appreciate the opportunity to respond to the Staffs comments. Please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned if you have any questions regarding this response letter.
Very truly yours, |
|
|
|
/s/ Daryl E. Raiford |
|
Daryl E. Raiford |
|
Chief Financial Officer |
|